If you have long feared that using a satellite navigation system to get to your destination is making you worse at finding the way alone, research now suggests your concern may be justified.

Scientists studying what navigation systems do to the brain have found that people using them effectively switch off parts of the brain that would otherwise be utilized to simulate different routes and boost navigational skills.

Publishing the findings in the journal Nature Communications on Tuesday, the researchers said that when volunteers in an experiment navigated manually, their hippocampus and prefrontal cortex brain regions had spikes of activity. But these were not seen when the volunteers simply followed satellite navigation devices’ instructions.

“When we have technology telling us which way to go … these parts of the brain simply don’t respond to the street network,” said Hugo Spiers of University College London’s (UCL) department of experimental psychology. “In that sense, our brain has switched off its interest in the streets around us.”

Long-term effects

The researchers said constant use of navigation systems would probably have longer-term limiting effects, making users less able to learn and navigate a city’s street network unaided.

“Understanding how the environment affects our brain is important,” said Amir-Homayoun Javadi, who worked on the UCL study before moving to the University of Kent. Satellite systems “clearly have their uses and their limitations.”

As an extension of the research, the scientists also analyzed the street networks of major cities around the world to visualize how easy they may be to navigate.

London, with its complex network of small streets, appears to be particularly taxing on the hippocampus, they said.

By contrast, far less mental effort may be needed to navigate Manhattan in New York, where a grid layout means that at most junctions, the choice is only between straight, left or right.
…